Contributor: Ruchin Kansal
To learn more about Ruchin, click here.
|
Research confirms a quality that predicts whether people will trust their leaders, stay in their organizations, and give their best work. And yet, almost no organization is deliberately developing it. It is benevolence.
The year was 2006. Five years out of business school, I was working at a top-tier consulting firm, helping launch a Japanese biopharma company in the U.S. The partner I worked with was recruited to launch a new consulting division at another organization. She brought me along. After a year of investment, the parent company decided to disband the division for various business reasons.
That created a serious problem for me. I was on an immigrant visa. My son was three years old. My wife was in the middle of her residency. A job loss meant leaving the U.S. with only a few months’ grace period. During that time, a senior leader hustled to land himself a position at another firm and got me the interviews, too. He didn’t have to, but he did. Within three weeks of learning I would lose my job, I had a new one.
That is a moment I will always remember. When I reflect on it, the words that come to mind are gratitude, relief, humility, and admiration. Those are the workplace moments that make you feel connected to the people in an organization, and, by extension, the organization itself. That quality is what research calls benevolence: whether a leader acts consistently in employees’ best interests and resists self-serving behavior. The everyday expression of that quality is what most of us would simply call kindness.
Why do I share this story? Because there is troubling data on workplace engagement, which directly connects to the need for moments like these.
I am the lead investigator on an IRB-approved Future of Leadership Survey conducted at Seton Hall University. Most leadership studies ask people already in leadership roles to define leadership. Very few studies ask emerging leaders what kind of leaders they want to become or what kind of leaders they want to work for. To address this gap, we launched this survey in 2021 and now have five years of longitudinal data, with over 12,000 responses across four continents.
In our 2024 cohort of over 4,200 respondents, 70 percent reported considering leaving their jobs in the past year.1 That is a big number, and the pattern is consistent. Respondents cited better salaries, burnout, and mental health concerns as primary drivers, alongside a persistent sense that leadership was not adequately investing in their development. So, beyond compensation, it really comes down to culture and leadership.
When we asked what values and character traits matter in a leader, the answer was also consistent across multiple years. Respondents want leaders who, first and foremost, “instill trust.” Also, leaders who are “continuous learners” and “admit mistakes.” Surprisingly, “driven by a higher purpose” ranked last with 81 percent favorable, a full 17 points behind instills trust at 98 percent. Everything you read says Gen Z wants purpose. The data says something different; they prioritize leaders who instill trust.
In 2025, we dug deeper into the role of trust. We tested the framework proposed by Mayer, Davis, and Schoorman (1995)2 and extended by Colquitt, Scott, and LePine (2007)3, suggesting that trust rests on ability (the skills and competencies enabling influence within a domain), integrity (adherence to mutually acceptable principles), and benevolence (belief that a trustee acts in the trustor’s best interest). We found that this model remains valid for our respondents.
Further, trust again emerged as the single strongest predictor of leadership effectiveness, and showed significant correlation with job satisfaction, retention, and employees’ own sense of growth and development.
What's truly revealing, though, is how trust is built versus how it’s lost. For building trust, ability leads the way, followed by integrity and then benevolence. But when trust is lost, something entirely different happens.
Think of a leader you have lost trust in. I would bet it was not because they could not do the job. And that is exactly what the data shows. When we asked respondents to think of a leader they no longer trusted and describe, in their own words, what a leader did to lose their trust, no theme centered on competence. The words that came back were “lied,” “self-serving,” “disrespectful,” “inconsistent,” and “condescending.” While 37% still credited that leader with the skills to do the job, 61% believed the leader was self-serving, and only 15% believed the leader strove to do good on their behalf. The lesson: Trust does not break because a leader lacks skill. It breaks because they stop caring or never did.
The timing is telling, too. The median time to build or lose trust is 12 months; however, respondents gave leaders 13 to 24 months to build trust. 44% reported losing trust within the first 6 months, and nearly 70% within the first year. People watch very carefully in year one. They are looking for cues on ability, integrity, and benevolence, and when benevolence and integrity turn negative, trust erodes quickly, and recovery is very hard.4
Consider what that means in practice: Ability is what we hire and train for. Integrity has organizational guardrails. Yet benevolence, genuine care for those you lead, is rarely central to our education, hiring processes, performance management, or leadership development. This raises two questions: Why not? And if benevolence can be built?
The answer to the second question came to me in a garage. In 2020, my son Neil expressed a desire to learn to drive a manual transmission. To do so, we bought a rusted, manual 1998 Acura Integra. He learned to drive it, and we rebuilt it from the ground up and drove it 5,000 miles to the summit of Mt. Evans, Colorado, the highest paved road in North America. We then restored a 1983 Alfa Romeo Spider and drove that 4,000 miles to Cape Spear, Canada, the easternmost point on the continent. We eventually co-authored a book about the experience, “The Kansal Clunker: The Car That Rebuilt Us,” which Kirkus Reviews called “an endearing and thought-provoking road odyssey.”
What the book is really about is how trust builds when two people commit to working through difficulties together, without a roadmap, without guaranteed success, and with the patience to listen to each other at every step. Benevolence is key, especially when things get hard, nothing works, and frustration turns into temper tantrums. In those moments, how you show up, how you react, and how you respond matter more than your ability to execute. It is a choice you make to show up for someone else, not just for you.
Benevolence can’t be acquired through reading alone. Like rebuilding that car, you cultivate it by doing the work: show up, put in the effort, and, most importantly, keep caring even when it's difficult.
Here are three things I would ask you to start doing today:
- One: Find out something about a person beyond their job title. Understand why they show up the way they do and do what they do. It will change the quality of your empathy.
- Two: Learn to listen. Challenge yourself to listen for five minutes without responding. Try to hear the message beneath what is being said.
- Three: Find one person you lead and invest in something that matters to them. Something they care about.
The data show a meaningful correlation among trust, job satisfaction, retention, and employees’ sense of development. Organizations hire for ability and manage for integrity. The benevolence deficit is real. We need to address this, starting at a personal level. Do the above three things consistently, and you will have done more to become an effective leader than any leadership development program ever could.
Contact Ruchin at [email protected].
References
- Kansal, R., Boroff, K., Caputo, A., & Johnson, B. (2024). The Future of Leadership Survey: 2024. In the Lead, Seton Hall University. Available at: https://www.shu.edu/leadership/news/the-future-of-leadership-survey-2024.html
- Mayer, R. C., Davis, J. H., & Schoorman, F. D. (1995). An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 709–734.
- Colquitt, J. A., Scott, B. A., & LePine, J. A. (2007). Trust, Trustworthiness, and Trust Propensity: A Meta-Analytic Test of Their Unique Relationships with Risk Taking and Job Performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 92(4), 909–927.
- Kansal, R., Boroff, K., & Caputo, A. (2025). The Trust Imperative: Next Generation Evidence for Leadership Effectiveness. In the Lead, Seton Hall University. Available at: https://www.shu.edu/leadership/news/next-generation-evidence-for-leadership-effectiveness.html