Recovering and Thriving Post-Pandemic: Part 8 - Dealing Successfully in Today’s Evolving Payer Environment

Contributors: Wren Keber and Lisa Soroka
To learn more about Wren and Lisa, click here.

 

Source: Pixabay

The payer landscape has become increasingly difficult to navigate, especially during a time when healthcare providers need to maximize revenue capture potential for financial stabilization post-COVID. This article offers our perspective on the current landscape, along with tactics to help diffuse and manage tensions, navigate the maze of competing priorities/imperatives, and reach mutually agreeable outcomes supporting providers.

Current Contracting Landscape and Tactics

Our first observation is that the negotiation life cycle is extended – negotiations that may have previously concluded within a six-month window are now taking nine or more. This extended timeline is often a result of ongoing negotiation on amended or new contract language (even as rates are finalized), as well as the effort it takes to engage in meaningful data-driven negotiations, requiring more analytic resources to build and verify sophisticated models. Negotiators today are more physically distributed, e.g., still working remotely. This introduces more variables to the mechanics of the negotiation, including multiple time zones, limited capacity for both face-to-face and virtual meetings, and other factors introducing new bottlenecks slowing progress.

In addition to longer timelines, we are also observing that the tenor of negotiations is changing. Interpersonal relationships tend to be a little more tense, and at times combative, than they were in years past. This is an understandable phenomenon, given the increased pressure that both sides are experiencing. These include:

table.jpg

In years past, provider terminations were very rare, only used in extreme circumstances when parties were very far apart, stalling the negotiations. The impact for all parties, including members, is significant – so terminations were considered extreme. These tactics are becoming more commonplace, where it is routine for providers to terminate their arrangements with payers without extreme circumstances at hand, and payers are more willing to accept terminations. Payers have started curating their networks and using terminations to force rate reductions. Even academic medical centers (“AMCs”), usually considered indispensable in payer networks, are now sometimes considered to be replaceable because other organizations are increasingly offering tertiary or quaternary care.

Providers are increasingly finding that decentralization through “remote first” work arrangements - or centralization and/or consolidation of multiple regions - are dramatically shifting how payer-provider relations teams connect with each other and with their communities. In years past, it was common for payers and providers to live and work in the same region, and as a result, deeper multi-year relationships were built over time. In today’s evolved work environment, these connections are being disrupted, removing some of the interpersonal aspects from relationships and in turn from the negotiations. Building a strong relationship helps drive forward negotiations in good faith.

Tactics

To navigate this complex landscape, providers should become more comfortable with conflict and be prepared to educate payer-side representatives on both their provider organization's unique situation, and regional market dynamics more broadly. To arrive at mutually beneficial outcomes, we recommend both parties meet via phone or video in advance of starting a negotiation to level-set desired objectives and lay out a path forward.

Data is increasingly making an impact on how providers can position themselves when describing the value they bring to the payer network. Provider organizations should come to negotiations armed with data on market position, margin and cost structure, as well as clearly thought-out, non-negotiable deal points informed by the analysis. For example, provider organizations should know break-even by line of business, payer, and product, so they can demonstrate and defend why reimbursement cannot fall below a certain threshold. As decision support functions have become more sophisticated, providers can model specific scenarios, rather than using high-level percentages or estimated ratios that might not accurately represent the micro-level impact on dollars. In addition to internal data such as cost and quality, external data sources, including price transparency disclosures are now available. Investing in capabilities to intake and manipulate transparency files unlocks visibility into traditionally opaque allowable amounts and can highlight if payers have introduced pricing disparity for similar services with similar value.

Providers should be prepared to discuss how they have been making investments (by adding staff, building programs, etc.) that may increase the value of the billable services for the payer and their members. These investments are often strong indicators the delivery system is focused on improving services – such as directly increasing quality, connectedness/stickiness in the community and with community partners and addressing health inequity and access. Examples include:

  • Building post-acute care networks for stepdown care, such as skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), through referral standards and/or shared resources.
  • Continuum of care partnerships among integrated and community-based organizations – ranging from social workers to inform acute care discharge planning, to referring to high-quality, cost-effective providers such as home health and non-institutional rehabilitation services (outpatient or in-home).
  • Building additional access points – virtual and/or physical – to extend existing services into underserved neighborhoods. In cases where these investments are not offset by new revenue, it is helpful to quantify the additive value they bring to the payer network to strengthen negotiations.

Aside from tactics related to negotiating rates impacting overall reimbursement levels, it is important to cover tactics focusing on arrangements that positively impact yield or promote other payer objectives (investment in health equity.) As organizations think through how best to improve yield, they are increasingly finding “outside the box thinking” being welcomed by health plan counterparts. Some examples include:

  • Partnering to agree on certain conditions where procedures are “gold carded” meaning that they are subject to abbreviated or lighter pre-authorization processes. This allows providers to deliver high-quality care under predetermined provisions without complex administrative burden. Aside from authorizing certain conditions, sometimes plans are open to “gold carding” providers for their full range of services. Congress even entertained this concept when the Gold Card Act was introduced in 2022. We continue to see interest by lawmakers and CMS in partnering with providers to reduce administrative burden.
  • Discussing how plans can partner with provider organizations to deliver supplemental benefits – especially because Medicare Advantage plans are increasingly deploying them. These may be services provider organizations, particularly large integrated delivery systems, are already offering without reimbursement, including connector/navigator services to non-clinical/social care services. Payers are increasingly interested in contracting for these services when already-established delivery systems are prepared to handle high volumes of screening, coordinating, and referring activities for these non-clinical services. When health systems are already engaged in some level of provision, any additional revenue can be very impactful.
  • Focusing on contract language that helps level the playing field between payers and providers, including not allowing unilateral amendments, retrospective audits and retroactive claims denials, pushing administrative policy into handbooks or online portals rather than in the contract document itself, and adding unnecessary steps which become roadblocks in the dispute resolution/escalation process. Other considerations apply depending on the specific situation among payers, providers, and third-party interests such as employer groups.

Conclusion

While the tactics we have covered here are not necessarily novel or transformational, they are critical in reacting to the increasingly difficult payer landscape framing today’s negotiations. As the pandemic continues to change the definition of business as usual, we have found negotiations that conclude favorably are a direct result of investing enough resources to support the process. We will focus the next installment on tactics that help drive forward alternative payments and other value-based arrangements against the same challenging backdrop.


Contact Wren at: [email protected]
Contact Lisa at: [email protected]