Contributor: Vidya Murthy, WEMBA’42
To learn more about Vidya, click here.

Healthcare is driven by the desire to improve the lives of others; and, in that pursuit, increasingly connected and software-driven solutions are being designed and delivered. Nearly every major medical device manufacturer talks about data as the game changer of our lifetimes, and software as a medical device is the fastest growing segment of device development. However, in 2024 the Change Healthcare cybersecurity attack, with costs estimated at $3B, and Crowdstrike’s global outage have shown us the dangers of poor security and technology practices.
Since the Health Insurance Portability and Protection Act (HIPPA) was signed into law in 1996, there’s been a headline grabbing healthcare security failure every year. In the last decade, these information leaks have evolved into security incidents that disrupt care delivery. This has ranged from clinics shut down due to ransomware, all the way to the tragic loss of multiple lives. As we barrel towards 30 years of trying to do better, it’s natural to ask, why aren’t things changing?
First and foremost: healthcare focuses on healthcare, i.e., the delivery of care. And when assessing the opportunity cost for digitization projects, it’s simply too steep to stop delivering care in favor of spending resources to secure business operations. Evidence has been found to show decreased patient outcomes after hospital ransomware attacks, even where a healthcare delivery organization (HDO) has a dedicated security effort in place.
It is heartening that the FDA has statutory authority and increasing expectations for devices entering the market. However, insecure legacy devices continue to operate in the wild and lack an incentive for consumers to replace them. This situation is especially damaging for rural care delivery, where devices and security budgets are even more constrained.
Now it would be one thing for security issues to exist and not have an active exploitation ecosystem. However, the presence of adversaries targeting healthcare in particular is robust and directly impacts the delivery of care and patients’ lives.
While many HDOs use cyber insurance to protect themselves, the reactive nature of this mitigation doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence. So, what's a proactive approach? Perhaps it starts with building out a security team. Unfortunately, security is a ruthless industry; it’s not conducive to newbies, it’s high in burnout, and it’s quite specialized. This reality means attracting security talent into an industry rife with challenges is a non-trivial amount of spend.
In a regulated industry, the hope might be that government intervention could be a sufficient motivator. The GAO has highlighted the need for increased investment in critical infrastructure security. Healthcare in particular has fractured regulatory oversight - which means individual efforts are emerging, but systemic change is still out of reach.
With all these constraints in mind, where does that leave us in expecting security change that will both be sustainable and scalable? I’m not without hope - I believe efforts are happening from the White House to grassroots clinically-specific improvements that are meaningful and inspiring. I also believe if healthcare does not heed the failures of critical infrastructure experienced in 2024, the rate of change will be far too slow.
While historically we may have been able to justify the prioritization of immediate care delivery over investing in security, the lines have blurred, and without immediate and impactful investment in security, we will soon be in a position where too frequently care cannot be delivered.
Contact Vidya at: [email protected]